問答(16%)
1. 試述不予急救醫囑(Do not Resuscitation Order)在我國現今醫療文化下可能造成的
法律及倫理爭議?
又,DNR與Advanced Care Planning的差別在哪裡?
答:
DNR醫囑引發的問題包含法律、倫理與文化等多種不同領域的問題
法律方面,目前國內DNR的法源依據為安寧緩和醫療條例,此條例只適用於嚴格定義的末期病人,目前實務上幾乎只有癌症末期病人可以預立意願書,拒絕病危時的心肺復甦術。對於意外事故或各種突發病症,或進展緩慢的不可逆疾病,是否應擴大此條例的適用十分爭議
倫理方面,DNR病人只是放棄無用的急救或維生措施,並非放棄一切醫療行為,故醫事人員應具有足夠的倫理素養,對於DNR的臨終病人,仍應盡最大的努力幫助其平順的走完人生的最後一段
文化方面,我國國情強調家族觀念,不同於於西方強調個人的自主決策與負責。雖然法律上是以病患本人的意願為準,DNR的簽署過程醫師仍應幫助病患與家屬間的溝通與協調,以期最後做出所有人都能接受的決策,減少爭議的產生,讓病人得到真正的善終
Advanced care planning
Advance Care Planning (ACP) is a voluntary process of discussion between an individual and their care providers irrespective of discipline. If the individual wishes, their family and friends may be included in the discussions. With the individual's agreement, this discussion should be recorded, regularly reviewed and communicated to key persons involved in their care.
An ACP discussion might include:
- the individual's concerns
- their important values or personal goals for care
- their understanding about their illness and prognosis
- preferences for types of care or treatment that may be beneficial in the future and the availability of these
2. 試述安寧療護中「幽谷伴行」的意義。(5分)
能積極時積極,當力有未迨時,仍會盡我所能的陪伴你,扶持你走到最後一刻
3. 請問醫師協助自殺(Physician-assisted Suicide)與安樂死(Euthanasia)之差別的倫
理爭議?(3分)
reference
Passive Euthanasia: Hastening the death of a person by altering some form of support and letting nature take its course. For example:
 | Removing life support equipment (e.g. turning off a respirator) or |
 | Stopping medical procedures, medications etc., or |
 | Stopping food and water and allowing the person to dehydrate or starve to death. |
 | Not delivering CPR (cardio-pulmonary resuscitation) and allowing a person, whose heart has stopped, to die. |
Active Euthanasia: This involves causing the death of a person through a direct action, in response to a request from that person. A well known example was the mercy killing in 1998 of a patient with ALS (Lou Gehrig's Disease) by Dr. Jack Kevorkian, a Michigan physician. His patient was frightened that the advancing disease would cause him to die a horrible death in the near future; he wanted a quick, painless exit from life. Dr. Kevorkian injected controlled substances into the patient, thus causing his death. Charged with 1st degree murder, the jury found him guilty of 2nd degree murder in 1999-MAR.
Physician Assisted Suicide: A physician supplies information and/or the means of committing suicide (e.g. a prescription for lethal dose of sleeping pills, or a supply of carbon monoxide gas) to a person, so that they can easily terminate their own life. The term "voluntary passive euthanasia" (VPE) is becoming commonly used. One writer 3 suggests the use of the verb "to kevork". This is derived from the name of Dr. Kevorkian, who has promoted VPE and assisted at the deaths of hundreds of patients. Originally he hooked his patients up to a machine that delivered measured doses of medications, but only after the patient pushed a button to initiate the sequence. More recently, he provided carbon monoxide and a face mask so that his patient could initiate the flow of gas.
Involuntary Euthanasia: This term is used by some to describe the killing of a person who has not explicitly requested aid in dying. This is most often done to patients who are in a Persistent Vegetative State and will probably never recover consciousness.
你同意醫師協助自殺嗎?為什麼?(3分)